I am on round number two in my search for BC’s best value priced beer. I picked up a six pack of Bowen Island Brewing Extra Pale Ale at the liquor store for $8.45 earlier this week. With help from Chris and my lovely wife I am now down to the last can, which I am nearly finished with at this very moment.
I bought this beer assuming it was brewed on Bowen Island, which I think is a fair assumption, but it is not. Bowen Island Brewing started out as a small cottage brewery off the coast of Vancouver on Bowen Island. The brewery changed hands multiple times in the late nineties eventually to become a brand owned by the NorthAm Group. The NorthAm Group is one of BC’s fastest growing brewing companies owning three popular BC beer brands; Bowen Island Brewing, KB, and Whistler Brewing all brewed in Kamloops at the KB Brewery.
The good people at the NorthAm Group are playing a sneaky game by selling beer, all of which is brewed in the same facility, under three separate brands with different pricing. I am intrigued by the similar reviews that KB, Bowen and Whistler Pale Ales share on Beer Advocate and Ratebeer.com. If all three brands are brewed at the same facility and under the supervision of the same brewmaster how can they be dramatically different from one another? Bowen Island, KB and Whistler all offer a Pale Ale – but are they different? Does Whistler beer use more expensive higher quality ingredients? Beer drinkers have a right to know this pertinent information.
I tried to get to the heart of the matter by sending an email to Bowen Island and KB Brewing – none have replied as of yet. Perhaps there is a perfectly good explanation and each brand is brewed with completely different recipes or my sources are incorrect and all three brands are completely unrelated, but without a response from the brewery I have no way of knowing. This unimpressive display of customer service is not making their beer taste any better. I have no desire to drink beer brewed by a company that is not honest with their customers. Over the next week I am hoping to solve this puzzle – I will post any new information as soon as possible. In the meantime, I have put together a breakdown of the three NorthAm brands:
Bowen Island Brewing – local value priced beer
KB Brewing – quality BC craft beer
Whistler Brewing – premium craft beer, leveraging Whistler’s international reputation
By now, the last glass of Pale Ale has vanished and I am feeling all the better for it – time to review. Bowen Island Brewing Extra Pale Ale is a surprisingly impressive beer for its price. It is a rich, copper coloured English Style Pale Ale with good head retention. Upon pouring, the beer releases a powerful aroma with sweet caramel leading the way followed by earthiness and a mild floral note. Similar to the aroma, caramel flavours are quite dominant but are somewhat balanced a medium hop finish. I would prefer this beer to be hoppier, but I tend to like hoppier beer. It was a bit thin, lacking any significant body. It is nice to find a pale ale from the Pacific Northwest that does not have a strong citrus flavour, not that I don’t like citrusy hops, it is just nice to change it up now and again.
This is a great session beer that is well suited for students, the unemployed (like me) or people who are just plain cheap. However, until I get to the bottom of NorthAm’s game of smoke and mirrors I do not feel comfortable recommending the beer to anyone.
Erik
Weren’t you saying that Whistler Brewing trucks Whistler water to Kamloops? I hope they do, everybody knows that Whistler water is way better than Kamloops water, totally different, in a classy Whistler way. It’s also great to hear that they are spending the extra money on trucking, polluting our environment all the while.
Yes, that really does happen. Why use perfectly good water from Kamloops when Whistler glacial water is so close by.
- “Bowen Island, KB and Whistler all offer a Pale Ale – but are they different? Does Whistler beer use more expensive higher quality ingredients? Beer drinkers have a right to know this pertinent information.”
I agree with you in spirit. However, I would say beer drinkers don’t really have a right to know what’s in there as much as they have a duty not to buy sub-standard crap in the first place!
I have been impressed with the quality of beer. I have tasted both the Bowen Island and Whistler beers, and have been impressed with our local product!
KB Brewing ofers only 1 product…Black Bear Ale.
Yes, Whistler water is trucked in specifically for the Whistler Beers…Export Lager,Honey Lager(made with fresh honey from a local beekeeper), Pale Ale, and my favorite, Black Tusk.
Bowen uses cold filtered water and also makes a lager,pale ale,and a honey(from same local beekeeper), but the malts used differ from the whistler products. No smoke, No mirrors.
Why does it matter if the water is filtered when it’s cold?
Occassionally a can ofBowen Island lager, which I purchase in cans is scunky……this has never happened in the more mainstream brands….hum?
The mainstream brands have preservation and shelf life down, but what food should last for two years? I prefer taste over shelf life, which means I’m going to get the odd bad bottle or can.
6 months average cottage beer lifespan. Beers with more hops like IPA’s will last longer as hops act as a preservative. As a rule, hoppier beers have a somewhat longer shelf life.
I have had many “Skunky” beer from bowen Island brand . If you e mail them and let them know they will give you Free ones to make you happy
! Try it ..I did ..;-)
This is a poor excuse for beer. I would not recommend this beer to anyone.
Bought a 15 pack of the lager and it tasted horrible.
I bought this beer having mistaken it for Granville Island to be truthfully honest; the labels are similar and i couldn’t quite remember the name. But I knew it was from B.C. and being a student, the price ($6.99 in Alberta,) was extraordinary! Plus the no preservatives is always a plus when you enjoy the pint as regularly as I do. Regardless, it’s GREAT. I am curious as to why it is so cheap though. Is it quite costly having additives & preservatives in beer? and how is Whistler water better than Kamloops? No fluoride?
Honestly Erik, you really need to do your research before you post slanderous crap like this. There are big differences between the brands and their particular flavours, being made in one brewery just means they need to have an extremely organized and outstanding crew. Just because you’re drunk and have an opinion doesn’t mean you have the right to discredit a company. There are no smoke and mirrors present, just one fogged up brain, sorry to disappoint you.
Hi Marcus, keeping in mind that Erik wrote this two years ago, what parts aren’t true today? I’d be interested to know and we’d be happy to post any information you have for us. Also, we get a lot of email from people (many of whom aren’t happy) thinking we are somehow affiliated with Bowen Island Brewing. If you work for them, might I suggest improving your online presence instead of making angry comments? Cheers, Chris