Tag Archives: bc beer awards

List of BC Beer Awards Judges

So the BC Beer awards last weekend have garnered much online attention.  I previously posted a few comments and the list of winners.  One thing I often wonder about beer awards is, who entered?  Something I wonder about less is, who judged?  Well, I happen to have a direct line of communication to the guys at Brewery Creek who put on these awards, so I asked them for both lists.  BTW, the direct line of communication I have with the guys at Brewery Creek is the cashier line.

I failed to get the list of entrants because Brewery Creek “[has] no interest in hi-lighting the losers”.  I totally get this and don’t begrudge them at all.  Similarly, nobody needs to know that I finished last in the grade seven district cross country race I foolishly entered or that I never finish last at sex.

Brewery Creek was much more accommodating when it came to the judges and I admire their transparency.  Turns out they put together a pretty respectable list of qualified beer tasters.  Below is the list as Brewery Creek sent it to me, though I added a few links when I knew who someone was.  Most of these people are super qualified and/or home-brewers actively involved with VanBrewers.

  • Nigel Springthrope : Beer Expert  - experienced judge – Never heard of him, owns Alibi Room?
  • Randy Shore: Media – Vancouver Sun’s The Green Man
  • Chad McCarthy: BJCP ranked beer judge – Cicerone, on Twitter
  • Tim Ellison: Sommelier  - experienced judge – PICA Instructor
  • Adam Henderson :BJCP ranked beer judge – Beer Importer and Cicerone
  • Dave Shea: BJCP in training – CSS Legend and Mobifier
  • Aaron Peterson : BJCP ranked beer judge
  • Bob Boufford: BJCP ranked beer judge
  • Danny Seeton: BJCP ranked beer judge
  • Ian Crook: BJCP ranked beer judge
  • Katy Wright: BJCP ranked beer judge
  • Liam Wake: BJCP ranked beer judge
  • David O’Halloran: BJCP ranked beer judge
  • Ben Coli: BJCP in training – experienced judge  - Sloppy Gourmand
  • Nicole Coetzee: BJCP in training  - experienced judge – Ginger Beer Blog
  • Scott Butchart: BJCP in training  - experienced judge
  • Rob Ardies: BJCP in training  - experienced judge

So yeah, they probably aren’t going to ask me to be a taster next year. For a few first hand accounts of the tasting process, check out this and this.

Cheers,

Chris

BC Beer Award Winners 2012

The BC Beer Awards were given out this past Saturday at Chapel Arts in Vancouver.  The event was coupled with the CAMRA Harvest Cask Fest, a signature event of the ongoing BC Craft Beer Month.  Let me tell you, serving beer for a few hours before giving out awards is really a great way to rouse up a crowd.

The standout beer on offer was the cask of Belgian Quince IPA from Lighthouse, which was phenomenal.  They should add this beer to their regular rotation and make it available via IV for me personally.  I was also very fond of the Chocolate Pumpkin Porter from Parallel 49 and of the four fresh hop beers on hand.  I won’t speak of the beers I didn’t care for, like the R&B Cucumber Mint IPA.  I won’t talk about how that beer raped my mouth from the inside.

bc harvest cask festival

Harvest Cask Festival mayhem

The coolest aspect of the event was that most of the brewers who won awards were actually there and a few were standing right beside me when they won.  I considered kidnapping Driftwood’s Jason Meyer and forcing him to brew for me personally (at gun point), but I didn’t think that would be fair to the rest of you.

I’ve been critical of the beer awards in the past.  The trouble is, you’ve got judges blind tasting beers and marking them versus a style  guideline.  This means that beers you might not expect to win end up beating your favourite beers.  I considered rioting when Fat Tug didn’t win any of the three IPA awards, but was placated with cask beer.  Anyway, much respect to the guys at Brewery Creek who put on this awards shindig.  I know they worked really hard and recruited some top notch tasters.  I really like that they list how many entries there were in each category.  I guess Fat Tug finishing 4th of 36 is okay.

bc beer awards

An actual BC Beer Award is a black dildo

Suggestions for next year, force every BC beer to enter!  I hear Brewery Creek has access to a lot of beer, so they should just pull a bottle of every BC beer off the shelf.  For example, Tofino didn’t enter this year and I think they could have won an award or two.  Second and most important suggestion, let me be a taster.  Come on, I’m incredibly unprofessional, biased, and fun to be around.  Put me in coach, I can play.

Here are the winners:

Best of Show – Steamworks Pilsner -Conrad Gmoser of Steamworks Brewing Company

Lager/Pilsner – 22 Beers

1.) Steamworks Pilsner – Conrad Gmoser of Steamworks Brewing Company
2.) Beach Blonde Lager – Stefan Buhl of Tree Brewing Company
3.) Kelowna Pilsner – Stefan Buhl of Tree Brewing Company

Special Lager – 8 Beers

1.) Brewmaster’s Black – Stefan Tobler of Okanagan Spring Brewery
2.) Hermann’s Dark Lager – Ralf Pittroff of Vancouver Island Brewery
3.) Iron Plow Harvest Marzen – Ralf Pittroff of Vancouver Island Brewery

Session – 17 Beers

1.) High Country Kolsch -Bart Larson of Mt. Begbie Brewing Company
2.) Seadog Amber Ale – Ralf Pittroff of Vancouver Island Brewery
3.) Begbie Cream Ale -Bart Larson of Mt. Begbie Brewing Company

Wheat/Rye – 22 Beers

1.) Belgian White – Paul Hoyne and Dean Mcleod of Lighthouse Brewing Company
2.) King Heffy Imperial Hefeweizen – Paul Wilson and Franco Corno of Howe Sound Brewing Company
3.) White Bark Ale – Jason Meyer and Kevin Hearsum of Driftwood Brewing Company

Pale – 41 Beers

1.) Red Racer Classic Pale Ale – Gary Lohin of Central City Brewing Company
2.) Salt Spring ESB – Murray Hunter of Gulf Island Brewing
3.) River Rock Bitter – Daniel Murphy of Canoe Brewpub

Cascadian Dark Ale – 4 Beers

1.) Skookum Cascadian Brown Ale – Matt Phillips of Phillips Brewing Company
2.) Gathering Storm Cascadian Dark Ale – Paul Wilson and Franco Corno of Howe Sound Brewing Company
3.) Cascadia Dark Ale – Tommie Grant of Spinnakers Brewpub and GuestHouses

Porter/Brown – 24 Beers

1.) Pow Town – Cedric Dauchot of Townsite Brewing Inc
2.) Dark Chocolate Porter – Paul Hoyne and Dean Mcleod of Lighthouse Brewing Company
3.) Longboat Chocolate Porter – Matt Phillips of Phillips Brewing Company

Scottish/Irish – 3 Beers

1.) Big Caboose Red Ale – Gord Demaniuk of Fernie Brewing Company

Fruit – 15 Beers

1.) Blackberry Festivale – Cedric Dauchot of Townsite Brewing Inc
2.) 4 Way Fruit Ale – Paul Wilson and Franco Corno of Howe Sound Brewing Company
3.) Seedspitter Watermelon Wit – Graham With of Parallel 49 Brewing Company

Stout – 14 Beers

1.) Keepers Stout – Paul Hoyne and Dean Mcleod of Lighthouse Brewing Company
2.) Pothole Filler Imperial Stout – Paul Wilson and Franco Corno of
Howe Sound Brewing Company
3.) Singularity – Jason Meyer and Kevin Hearsum of Driftwood Brewing Company

IPA – 36 Beers

1.) 5 Rings IPA – Derrick Franche of High Mountian Brewing Company
2.) Central City Imperial IPA – Gary Lohin of Central City Brewing Company
3.) Red Racer IPA – Gary Lohin of Central City Brewing Company

Sour/Brett – 4 Beers

1.) Oud Bruin – Iain Hill of Yaletown Brewing Company
2.) Bird Of Prey Flanders Red – Jason Meyer and Kevin Hearsum of
Driftwood Brewing Company
3.) Imperial Flanders – James Walton of Storm Brewing Ltd

Specialty – 20 Beers

1.) Smoke & Mirrors Imperial Smoked Ale – Kevin Emms of Coal Harbour Brewing
2.) Serendipity #5 – Stefan Buhl of Tree Brewing Company
3.) Schadenfreude Pumpkin Oktoberfest – Graham With of Parallel 49 Brewing Company

Strong – 7 Beers

1.) Hermannator Ice Bock – Ralf Pittroff of Vancouver Island Brewery
2.) Old Cellar Dweller 2012 – Jason Meyer and Kevin Hearsum of
Driftwood Brewing Company
3.) Bourbon Barrel Aged Thor’s Hammer – Gary Lohin of Central City Brewing Company

Cheers,

Chris

October is BC Craft Beer Month 2012

You may not have heard, but this October is the second annual BC Craft Beer month.  For the uninitiated, BCCBM is like Vancouver Craft Beer Week, but events happen throughout October and all over BC.  Events include cask nights, brewmaster dinners, food pairing, parties and festivals.  I’m most looking forward to the BC Beer Awards and Harvest Cask beer fest, a combined BCCBM signature event.  I’ve discussed beer awards generally in the past, so I’m looking forward to seeing how the BC Beer Awards go.  More likely I’ll have enjoyed too much of the plentiful harvest cask fest to know what’s going on.

bc craft beer month

Anyway, check out the snazzy new BC Craft Beer Month website, which appears to be just a map.  I really like the concept and design of the magical map/site, but there seem to be some bugs related to zooming in on places where there are multiple events.  Try filtering by date or event type to figure out what’s the what.  Happy BC Craft Beer Month!

Cheers,

Chris

BC Beer Awards 2012

BC Beer AwardsSpeak of the devil, shortly after I write a post criticizing beer awards, the BC Beer Awards are announced.  I swear I didn’t know this was going to happen. Notably, in previous years this event was done in conjunction with Vancouver Craft Beer Week.  Interesting that the 3rd beer awards didn’t line up with the 3rd VCBW, do I smell a rift?

I really like a few things I see in the press release below.  First, they clearly state that they’ll only have twelve categories, that these will be inclusive of all BC beers, and that judging will be based on taste.  Second, this event will be going on at the same time as CAMRA’s Harvest Cask Festival.

I’m not super keen on the idea of celebrity judges.  What if they like lime flavoured beers? I hope these celebrity judges are carefully vetted. Do marginally talented beer bloggers count as celebrities?  If so, I’m hereby volunteering to judge.

Press release below.

Cheers,

Chris

THE BRITISH COLUMBIA BEER AWARDS RETURN TO VANCOUVER ON OCTOBER 13TH!

3rd Annual Event Showcases the Very Best of Local Beer and Brewers

Vancouver, BC – June 27, 2012 - We’re back!!

Eagerly anticipated by BC beer fans and brewers alike, the 3rd Annual British Columbia Beer Awards, sponsored by The Brewery Creek Liquor Store and in partnership with CAMRA BC, is set to return to our city to help launchBC Craft Beer Month on Saturday, October 13th, 2012.

One of the most focused beer events in Western Canada, the BC Beer Awards showcases and celebrates the very best of locally-made beer.  Open to the public, this one-day-only event will be held this year at Chapel Arts(304 Dunlevy, Vancouver) and will include not only the awards ceremony itself, but also CAMRA’s Harvest Cask Festival, with food provided by some of Vancouver’s acclaimed and beer-friendly restaurants. 

Last year’s award ceremony included over 400 unique entries from over 35 BC breweries and brewpubs, with winners selected in 12 distinct categories.  Judges included certified Beer Judges, Cicerones, Sommeliers, Journalists, as well as noted beer and food lovers.

Highlights from the forthcoming 2012 event will include: 

* A one-day-0nly afternoon event that includes both the 2012 BC Beer Awards presentation ceremony, as well as the hotly-anticipated CAMRA’s Harvest Cask Festival consumer tasting.

* Certified Judges paired alongside celebrity panellists in order to increase festival attendance and exposure.

* Participation of acclaimed Vancouver restaurants.

The primary goal of the BC Beer Awards is to reward excellent beers even if not brewed exactly to strict style guidelines. Secondary is ensuring that every beer brewed in BC can be entered regardless of whether it fits in a style or not.  A preliminary list of categories will be issued shortly, with reference to the various BJCP (Beer Judge Certification Program) categories they include.  

Tickets for the 2012 BC Beer Awards, including the awards ceremony and Cask Festival are set to go on sale on September 1st.  Please visit www.BCBeerAwards.com for the latest updates.

The Trouble with Beer Awards

Every time I visit a tasting room, beer or wine, I see a lot of awards on display.  It seems like every product is an award winner of sorts.  But if every beer is an award winner, how are we, the gullible consumer, supposed to know what is actually the best?  Most breweries use “award winning” in their marketing, a message I find misleading.

central city canadian beer awards

Central City’s Canadian Brewing Awards, including brewery of the year

I really like the idea of beer awards.  They give brewers something to strive for, they provide the chance for brewers to commingle, and they sound like really fun times.  That being said, whenever I see a press release by an event or brewery bragging about some new award, I think about these things:

  1. Brewers pay to enter - An entry usually costs $100 per beer.  This means that only brewers willing to pay up (say $500 to a $1000 per product line per event) are actually judged.
  2. Who actually entered?  – Almost no beer awards list all of the entrants in each category, only the winners.  The gold medal for best IPA doesn’t mean much if only a handful of beers were actually entered.  I feel like full disclosure is warranted, otherwise how can we trust the authenticity of an award?
  3. There are too many categories - Most events have 30+ categories.  I feel like some categories are invented so that macro breweries win (sponsorship money?).  Consider that breweries are more likely to enter if they think they can win and that awards events have an economic interest in soliciting as many entries as possible.  Making everyone a winner seems like a pretty good deal for all involved.
  4. Beer is judged on style, not taste - If a beer most closely matches the style guidelines of its designation, it wins gold in that category.  Maybe this is the only way to judge beer, but I’d much rather prefer an award based on taste.  A bad tasting beer that is very exemplary of a style beats a very good tasting beer, wtf?
  5. What beer was actually served?  - Where did the beer the judge tasted come from?  Did it come from a bottle off the shelf? Did it come from a cask, brewed specially for the awards?  How did the beer get there?  How was it stored?  When was it brewed?  How do we know the playing field was completely level?
  6. There are a lot of awards -  There are so many awards events and so many categories that everyone wins, rendering the whole idea of awards pretty useless. It’s like primary school sports day all over again, here’s your (Pabst) blue ribbon!

I’m writing this post because the winners of the Canadian Brewing Awards were just announced, an event I’ve written about before.  There were 44 BC winners out of 111 possible awards, most of whom I consider deserving.  Central City was named Canadian Brewery of the Year, which I think is totally awesome.  While I’m very proud of how well BC did, I have seriously misgivings about these awards.  First, check out the list of categories and the eventual winners.  Now take a look at the entry form and consider the points I made above.  Some key questions:

  • What the hell is Phillips Blue Buck Pale Ale doing in the North American Amber Lager category?  It’s a pale ale and it won a silver medal as an amber lager?  Somebody made a serious mistake there.
  • What’s the difference between lager and premium lager?
  • Why is there a category for light beer?  Shoot me in the head.
  • How did Moosehead win four times?
  • How did three terrible beers win in the fruit category?
  • How did Driftwood, Central City, and Dieu du Ciel not win in every category of each beer they make?

These awards just seem incredibly incomplete to me.  I won’t be buying beer based on the medals they gave out. I have more hope for the BC Beer awards, which are slated to resurface this October as part of BC Craft Beer Month.  Here’s hoping they do our province proud.

Cheers,

Chris